Monday, June 20, 2011

Fret King Vs Tonerider (Vs Iron Gear) - Part 2

The new Tonerider alnico IV classic pickup arrived at the end of last week. They were described as "Black White Zebra" so I was hoping the light coil would be white, but it ended up being the usual cream colour which was a bit annoying. I could have sent it back, but I was far too excited. 
The plan was to try just the bridge PU and see how it goes before buying the neck.  In some ways it seems crazy to replace the Wilkinsons with Toneriders as they RRP at £50 to the Toneriders £35.
I stuck them in over the weekend:

All the tools in place:

The control cavity turned out to be a bit busier than I was expecting. 

I was initially a bit puzzled how it worked but then worked out that the pickup cables were spliced onto a grey cable that headed off to the pickup switch on the scratchplate. The volume pot was another solder Malteser so I decided as I was doing one wire as a splice I would do them both that way. 

Pickup installed!

I put the old strings back on as I figured I would be taking them off soon to change the neck one. First impressions are very good. The Tonerider sounds very different to the Wilkinson. Loads brighter which was one of the things I was really looking for as the current one is a little too dark for strumming. The broad tonal difference means they don't blend all that well so another pickup was required in short order. I decided on an Iron Gear Alchemist humbucker sized P90. The only reason for using this over the Tonerider Rebel 90 was that the Rebel was out of stock at the time. 

It shipped today so I'll post some comparison clips when everything is installed. Including the Axetec strings which cost a staggering £2.60 a set!


Fret King Vs Tonerider (Vs Iron Gear) - Part 2

The new Tonerider alnico IV classic pickup arrived at the end of last week. They were described as "Black White Zebra" so I was hoping the light coil would be white, but it ended up being the usual cream colour which was a bit annoying. I could have sent it back, but I was far too excited. 
The plan was to try just the bridge PU and see how it goes before buying the neck.  In some ways it seems crazy to replace the Wilkinsons with Toneriders as they RRP at £50 to the Toneriders £35.

I was initially a bit puzzled how it worked but then worked out that the pickup cables were spliced onto a grey cable that headed off to the pickup switch on the scratchplate. The volume pot was another solder Malteser so I decided as I was doing one wire as a splice I would do them both that way. 

Pickup installed!

I put the old strings back on as I figured I would be taking them off soon to change the neck one. First impressions are very good. The Tonerider sounds very different to the Wilkinson. Loads brighter which was one of the things I was really looking for as the current one is a little too dark for strumming. The broad tonal difference means they don't blend all that well so another pickup was required in short order. I decided on an Iron Gear Alchemist humbucker sized P90. The only reason for using this over the Tonerider Rebel 90 was that the Rebel was out of stock at the time. 

It shipped today so I'll post some comparison clips when everything is installed. Including the Axetec strings which cost a staggering £2.60 a set!

Fret King Vs Tonerider (Vs Iron Gear) - Part 2

The new Tonerider alnico IV classic pickup arrived at the end of last week. They were described as "Black White Zebra" so I was hoping the light coil would be white, but it ended up being the usual cream colour which was a bit annoying. I could have sent it back, but I was far too excited. 
The plan was to try just the bridge PU and see how it goes before buying the neck.  In some ways it seems crazy to replace the Wilkinsons with Toneriders as they RRP at £50 to the Toneriders £35.

I was initially a bit puzzled how it worked but then worked out that the pickup cables were spliced onto a grey cable that headed off to the pickup switch on the scratchplate. The volume pot was another solder Malteser so I decided as I was doing one wire as a splice I would do them both that way. 

Pickup installed!

I put the old strings back on as I figured I would be taking them off soon to change the neck one. First impressions are very good. The Tonerider sounds very different to the Wilkinson. Loads brighter which was one of the things I was really looking for as the current one is a little too dark for strumming. The broad tonal difference means they don't blend all that well so another pickup was required in short order. I decided on an Iron Gear Alchemist humbucker sized P90. The only reason for using this over the Tonerider Rebel 90 was that the Rebel was out of stock at the time. 

It shipped today so I'll post some comparison clips when everything is installed. Including the Axetec strings which cost a staggering £2.60 a set!

Fret King Vs Tonerider (Vs Iron Gear) - Part 2

The new Tonerider alnico IV classic pickup arrived at the end of last week. They were described as "Black White Zebra" so I was hoping the light coil would be white, but it ended up being the usual cream colour which was a bit annoying. I could have sent it back, but I was far too excited. 
The plan was to try just the bridge PU and see how it goes before buying the neck.  In some ways it seems crazy to replace the Wilkinsons with Toneriders as they RRP at £50 to the Toneriders £35.
I stuck them in over the weekend:

All the tools in place:

The control cavity turned out to be a bit busier than I was expecting. 

I was initially a bit puzzled how it worked but then worked out that the pickup cables were spliced onto a grey cable that headed off to the pickup switch on the scratchplate. The volume pot was another solder Malteser so I decided as I was doing one wire as a splice I would do them both that way. 

Pickup installed!

I put the old strings back on as I figured I would be taking them off soon to change the neck one. First impressions are very good. The Tonerider sounds very different to the Wilkinson. Loads brighter which was one of the things I was really looking for as the current one is a little too dark for strumming. The broad tonal difference means they don't blend all that well so another pickup was required in short order. I decided on an Iron Gear Alchemist humbucker sized P90. The only reason for using this over the Tonerider Rebel 90 was that the Rebel was out of stock at the time. 

It shipped today so I'll post some comparison clips when everything is installed. Including the Axetec strings which cost a staggering £2.60 a set!

Monday, June 13, 2011

Fret King Vs Tonerider - Part 1

Media_httpi19photobuc_frggr

The Iron Gear pickups I added to my Strat were a great success. I was very impressed that Chinese made budget pickups could make a big improvement to a vintage US Strat but indeed they did. There was quite a bit of debate on the sound clips on Music Radar. I preferred the new pickups from the get go but a tweak to the heights and they now sound amazing. I'm never going to go back to spending twice or three times the price on Seymour Duncans. 

Since installing the Iron Gears my beloved Fret King has started to sound somewhat ordinary in comparison so I started planning my next pickup upgrade project. Lots of great advice was forthcoming on the thread I started on Music Radar.
I was torn between getting another set of Iron Gears which I already knew were excellent and trying out the pickups made by Tonerider which had glowing recommendations from a number of people. I already have a Tonerider British Distortion pedal which was great value for money and puts a big grin on my face when ever I use it (seriously check out the clips) so I had no worries about using them or their distributors Dangeberry Music. 

To help me decide I sent an e-mail to both companies asking what they would recommend. Both companies replied within a day which is seriously good customer service in my book. Iron Gear recommended the Rolling Mill and Tonerider suggested either the Alnico IV or the Rock Song.
I'm sure I can't go wrong whoever I choose, but as I'd already put some business Iron Gear's way I thought I would take a punt on the Toneriders and ordered an Alnico IV from Dangleberry as I liked the clips on the site bit more.

As they sell them individually I went for just a bridge to see if I like it. Rather than sticking to the nickel covers it came with I've gone for the rather more gauche zebra coils. 

As with last time I'll record some before and after sound clips for your delectation and comment.